I’ve had a love affair with cars ever since I was a little kid. At some point I ended up with over 70+ matchboxes which were stamped “Made in England”. Sadly, those times [stuff made anywhere other than China] are gone. But not, my love of cars. I was once informed by an acquaintance that “when you start driving a bit, your love of cars will fade”. Well, not only has it NOT faded, I recently took an M3 out for a spin, and it fed that love like a plane belly full of jet fuel being unceremoniously dumped onto a forest fire.
In this piece however, I’m going to write about something a little more vanilla. For a little over three years now, I’ve owned a BMW 325i Coupe. It’s a gorgeous, sleek little thing, and I [my wife] relished selecting the colours and options when buying time rolled around. It has a few niggles. Its power is a little bit low….. …wait a minute, that’s actually the only niggle…… Alright, alright, there is one more – the gear box in Sport Mode can be a little notchy – but only if you’re NOT driving it flat to the floor. Drive it full stick and the sport mode gear shift is smooth. Drive it around town in Sport and it’s clunky and notchy as heck. Normal “Drive” is fine and smooth enough, though it should be smoother. I think the latest box [8 speed] has fixed all this though. In the M3 (2010 build), I’d gotten to 5th gear in the blink of an eye with the new double clutch wonder. Scary, scary fast. In the 320i, hitting a roundabout tricks the gearbox into thinking it needs to select a higher gear – so you end up “stuck” half way around the corner with no power. Weird and unsettling.
Anway, so I’ve had this thing (325i Coupe now) up to silly speeds on blind, tight corners which go up and down steep hills. It inspires confidence like nothing else I’ve driven – except for a little Peugeot 205GTI I once owned – but that’s for a different piece…..I’ve even had a WRX (with some, ah, modifications) on the same piece of tarmac – and guess what? The beamer felt safer and was actually going much faster. Though, it FELT slower. HOW do the Germans DO THAT? Even at 160kmh, this vehicle feels like you’re doing around 80……
So just to piss me off a touch, someone decided to rear end my pride and joy just after Christmas. Not a huge amount of damage, but enough. Thankfully, he was insured. But of course, one then worries that it won’t be quite the same. Can they match the paint just right? Will there be orange peel? Will they take the trouble to put all the bits and pieces back EXACTLY how there were? In short, will it look factory? Well guess what, this smash repair mob I found (okay, okay, that the dealer recommended) did the work in just over a week, and, IT LOOKS FACTORY. Ask anyone how difficult I am to please and they’ll say – “Dezzie should work in quality control – trouble is, the company he’d work for would go broke ‘cause he’d never pass anything”!
Just to stray for a moment – whilst my beloved was getting her rear end fixed, they gave me, as a loaner, a BMW 320i. Four door. Interesting. Less power, more doors, newer. Shouldn’t be all bad, right?
Here we go:
325i coupe pros:
Power. Smoothness. Build. Agility. For lack of a better word, “feel”.
My couple is about $30-40k more than the sedan. What do you get for that extra, hard earned cash which could go towards a Bayliner? Driving both vehicles back to back, you can see exactly where that extra cash went. Better leather. Better sound suppression. A larger, more powerful and smoother motor of course. If you’ve ever experienced the silky smooth power output of a BMW, 2.5 litre six cylinder, you’ll know approximately what heaven is – downshift downhill whilst pulling 4 thousand revs? No probs, you’ll barely feel the engine absorbing all that energy. An old Commodore 3.8 litre would SCREAM in protest by comparison. The 4 cylinder in the 320i too, feels like farm machinery by comparison. Clunky. Rattles. Don’t even THINK about putting low octane in it – you’ll then be burning twice as much; and the car will develop a pronounced LIMP. The suspension (back on the coupe, at speed) is better when pushed hard. Electric everything. An LCD screen which is your interface to the car (when you get into a car without one, it feels like you’re blind). It really is a different car and you’d swear they came from different manufacturers. The switch gear feels better manufactured. Sure, all the switches and instruments are relatively similar and LOOK the same, the 4dr has that exact same layout, but really, it felt like a slightly glorified 1 Series.

Oh, and brakes. I LOVE brakes. Outstanding, not just good, POWERFUL brakes. I once took a Porsche 911 Carrera back to a dealer after just 15 minutes because I thought the brakes were shot – “no, they’re fine ”said the dealer. Consider this, I’d adored Porsches ever since I was a boy – and now was potentially going to buy one and realise another dream. Heck, the dealer threw me the keys and told me to take as long as I wanted. Sheesh. What a disappointment. My boyhood dream was shattered. $220K for that? No thanks. I can confidently say that BMW more than likely have the best anchors in the business. Even a Series V RX7 I used to own (which supposedly was engineered for the racetrack) had woeful brakes for something which was supposed to be a sportscar you could take to the track.
For comparison, I slammed the brakes on with that M3 I took out recently and nearly got hurled through windshield. NOW you’re talking! BETTER than my car’s stoppers which are already outstanding (and the size of French dinner plates).
Very simply, the Coupe feels like a much bigger, and better built vehicle. Kinda like comparing a 560SEL to a Suzuki Swift.
Back to the 320i. It has smaller wheels, in both width and diameter, so it handled Sydney’s pock-faced roads a little better. This is not something which bothers me though. I’ve turned avoiding potholes into something of an art form. Got to protect those 18s! Then there’s clearance. Even pulling into a fuel station is a SLOW affair with the coupe, whose nose and lip sit VERY LOW to the ground. Imagine if I’d sprung for the M suspension which lowers the car even further. With the sedan, no such concerns. Just slam that thing up the ramp…..any ramp.
Fuel. Hands down, the 320i wins. It hardly drinks a thing. My son fell asleep in the back one particularly hot afternoon so when I got to my destination, I parked the car and left the engine running to keep the a/c going for nearly an hour. Fuel gauge didn’t move one bit. Again, a small plus, but a plus nonetheless. Especially with oil nearing US$90 odd per barrel. But once I get an M3, this point is moot. The M3 sports a four litre V8 which whilst very frugal (for a V8), is STILL a V8. Fuel economy? What’s that?
Let me spell it out for you. I was very disappointed in the 320i, and would never, ever buy one. For the same money, there are better vehicles out there. Heck, you can buy a second hand 7 series for the money. And those cars are LOADED and drive beautifully.
No, the coupe will stay in the garage for a little bit longer………
A few other things – the boot in my car is actually quite large. I’ve tested some gear (read, a huge pram) in a 5 series and an X5 – guess what? They aren’t that much bigger than the Coupe’s boot. You can stuff enough luggage in the coupe to keep a woman happy for a week – now how big is that???
P.S.
A final word – the 4 door sedan that I drove was made in South Africa. My coupe is made in Germany.